Which one gives more food for the money?
The Valley 28-Day costs $16.59 per 2,000-calorie day; the Mountain House Classic costs $43.81. That is about 2.6 times more for the same calories. In days of food for one person: 3.1 days in the Mountain House Classic for $134.49, 27.0 days in the Valley 28-Day for $448.
How long does each kit last?
The Valley 28-Day holds 54,000 cal, about 27.0 days for one person or 6.8 days for a family of four. The Mountain House Classic holds 6,140 cal, about 3.1 days for one person. Added up from the nutrition panels on Mountain House’s page: 12 pouches, 2 servings each (Spaghetti 250, Stroganoff 280, Chicken Fried Rice 300, Granola 250, Beef Stew 210 calories per serving). Valley Food Storage says the kit “averages 54,000 total calories”.
Which is easier to prepare?
Mountain House: Add hot water to the pouch and wait the time printed on the meal. Valley Food Storage: Preparation is printed on each bag; the kit page does not give one method. If your plan has no stove, the Mountain House Classic is the more practical of the two.
Shelf life, as each brand states it
Mountain House: Backed by Mountain House’s 30-Year Taste Guarantee. Valley Food Storage: 25-year shelf life when properly stored and sealed (Valley Food Storage).
Returns and the fine print
Mountain House: no returns on food unless damaged or defective. No returns on food unless defective, damaged or a receiving discrepancy; claims within 30 days of delivery. Valley Food Storage: 30 days. 30-day returns through Valley’s portal; unused food is refunded if returned in the condition received.
Allergens
Mountain House: Listed per meal on the page; Beef Stew and Chicken Fried Rice are labeled gluten-free, the other three are not. Valley Food Storage: Valley lists allergens per meal: mostly milk and wheat, plus egg, soy, coconut and fish in some recipes.
Stock on Nov 15, 2026
Sold out at Mountain House on Nov 15, 2026. In stock at Valley Food Storage on Nov 15, 2026. Best kit in stock on the same formula: My Patriot Supply 4-Week Emergency Food Supply.
Who should buy which?
Choose the Mountain House Classic for
- Go-bags, cars and camping trips
- People who want meals with zero cooking
- Anyone who values a 30-year taste guarantee
The catch: Only about 3 days of food at 2,000 calories for $134.49, the highest cost per day in our comparison, and food is not returnable unless defective.
Choose the Valley 28-Day for
- Buyers who want a month in one order
- Households that like resealable bags they can dip into
- People who want 30 days to return unused food
The catch: Valley gives no weight, no total water and no fixed menu for this kit; selections “may include” and items can be substituted.
Full reviews: Mountain House Classic Meal Assortment Bucket review · Valley Food Storage 28-Day Food Supply (350 Servings) review. Rankings: best emergency food supply · best emergency food supply company. Guide: freeze-dried vs dehydrated food.
Other head-to-heads: Mountain House vs ReadyWise · Augason Farms vs Mountain House · 4Patriots vs My Patriot Supply · Augason Farms vs ReadyWise. Or build your own in the comparison tool.


